
I'm Supposed to Be Grateful. So Why Am I Miserable?
Ah, November. The month we're all supposed to focus on gratitude and thankfulness.
But what if, instead of feeling grateful, you feel absolutely miserable?
Your marriage isn't working. You hate your job. You're exhausted all the time. You're surrounded by people, but you've never felt more alone.
And everywhere you turn, someone is telling you to be grateful.
"At least he's a good provider." "You're lucky to have a job." "Be thankful you have people who need you." "You have so many people who love you."
And then there's that endless loop inside your own head: YOU HAVE SO MUCH TO BE GRATEFUL FOR!
Well, isn't that helpful?
Now you're miserable AND you feel guilty about being miserable. And November has barely started.
How many times have you used gratitude to talk yourself out of acknowledging what's actually happening in your life?
You're hurt, so you tell yourself to be thankful. You're lonely, so you remind yourself how many people love you. You're exhausted, so you start counting your blessings.
And whatever was troubling you is still there.
That's performative gratitude.
You've learned how to say all the right things about how blessed you are while ignoring what you're actually experiencing. And you've gotten so good at it that you may not even recognize when you're doing it.
Who Taught You to Do This?
Think back. What happened when you were growing up and you complained about something? Did someone listen? Or did you hear:
"You have nothing to complain about." "Other children would be grateful to have what you have." "Stop feeling sorry for yourself." "I'll give you something to cry about."
Maybe expressing disappointment got you labeled selfish. Maybe you were praised for being the child who never complained. Or perhaps you learned these messages later, in a marriage, at work, or in church.
Some of the people who said these things were repeating what they'd been taught themselves. And those messages may have been passed down for generations.
When your feelings are repeatedly dismissed, you can learn to dismiss them yourself.
You express a feeling. Someone tells you why you shouldn't have it. You learn to keep it to yourself.
Eventually, you don't even need someone else to do it.
You do it for them.
You're hurt, and you immediately explain why you shouldn't be. You're angry, and you tell yourself you're overreacting. You're unhappy, and you start listing everything that's good about your life.
Whose voice are you hearing? And how long have you been repeating it?
Since When Do You Have to Justify How You Feel?
You're unhappy. You're angry. You're disappointed. And before you've even had a chance to understand why, you're already building a case against yourself.
"You have a good husband." "Other people have it worse." "So many people would love to have your life."
Okay. And?
Does having a good salary mean you can't dread going to work? Does having a family mean you can't feel lonely? Does loving someone mean you can't be deeply hurt by them?
Since when did having something good in your life disqualify you from having a problem?
You don't have to convince anyone that your pain is serious enough to deserve attention. You don't have to compare it to someone else's or find something positive about it.
Maybe what you're feeling is connected to something happening right now. Maybe it touches something you've carried for years. Maybe you don't know why it hurts so much.
You don't have to justify your pain. And you're allowed to feel it. And it might be a while before you're even ready to talk to someone else about it.
Awareness Is Where Healing Begins
So where do you begin?
Start with one question: What's happening in my life that I've been telling myself I shouldn't feel bad about?
Write down what's happening. Then write down the sentence you usually use to dismiss it.
For example:
"My husband and I barely talk anymore."
"At least he's a good provider."
Now look at those two statements. Does the second one do anything to address the first?
The second statement may be true. The first one still deserves attention.
If you've recognized yourself in this pattern, congratulations! That's a significant moment of awareness.
Think about how many years you may have repeated these messages without questioning them. But you've just stopped long enough to recognize one.
Give yourself credit for that. Awareness gives you something to work with.
Now, I want you to pay attention to something.
When you acknowledge that you're unhappy, what happens inside you? Does guilt show up? Do you immediately feel selfish? Do you hear that familiar voice telling you you're making too much of things?
Where did you learn that?
Think about the first time you remember being told that your feelings weren't okay. You may not remember a particular incident, but you might recognize the message.
And here's something you can practice. The next time you catch yourself dismissing your feelings, stop. Notice what you're feeling, including what's happening in your body.
Then tell yourself, "This is what I'm feeling. I don't have to explain it away."
That's a different response from the one you've been practicing for years.
And every time you recognize that old pattern, you have another opportunity to respond differently.
This November, Listen to Yourself
The gratitude messages will be everywhere. Count your blessings. Look on the bright side. Remember how fortunate you are.
But when something hurts, pay attention to what happens next.
Do you acknowledge it? Or do you immediately start listing all the reasons you shouldn't feel that way?
The next time that familiar voice starts screaming YOU HAVE SO MUCH TO BE GRATEFUL FOR!
Ask yourself:
What am I feeling that I keep trying to talk myself out of?
You don't have to explain it to anyone. You don't have to make a plan. And you don't have to find a blessing hidden in the pain.
For now, tell yourself the truth. And let yourself feel it.
If you'd like to look more closely at where these messages started, my free guided reflection, Who Did I Learn to Become?, can help you trace them.
